<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<reviews itemIdentifier="blind_blake_police_dog_blues">
  <review review_id="21498">
    <review_id>21498</review_id>
    <reviewbody>Blind Blake is one of the gods of Delta blues acoustic guitar.  This song is as fresh as the day it was recorded a lifetime ago.</reviewbody>
    <reviewtitle>Police Dog Blues</reviewtitle>
    <reviewer>AcidBluesMarty</reviewer>
    <reviewdate>2004-09-24 07:03:20</reviewdate>
    <createdate>2004-09-24 07:03:20</createdate>
    <stars>5</stars>
  </review>
  <review review_id="28888">
    <review_id>28888</review_id>
    <reviewbody>I play the Stefan Grossman version of this as an instrumental (along with countless other blues players) where all the guitar breaks are extracted and strung together, but have never heard the complete song version until now.  It's a classic blues song and a masterful guitar piece. Looks like I've got to learn the complete version now! Thank you InternetArchive, I have not heard this anywhere else.</reviewbody>
    <reviewtitle>Police Dog Blues</reviewtitle>
    <reviewer>Tricone John</reviewer>
    <reviewdate>2005-01-12 06:23:44</reviewdate>
    <createdate>2005-01-12 06:23:44</createdate>
    <stars>5</stars>
  </review>
  <review review_id="56287">
    <review_id>56287</review_id>
    <reviewbody>Classic 12-bar blues (&lt;a href="http://settlet.fateback.com/Para125.htm"&gt;Paramount 12888-A&lt;/a&gt;; recorded 1929-08-17; flip side to "&lt;a href="http://www.archive.org/audio/audio-details-db.php?collection=opensource_audio&amp;collectionid=Blind_Blake-Diddie_Wa_Diddie"&gt;Diddie Wa Diddie&lt;/a&gt;") by &lt;a href="http://www.blueson.se/blindblake.htm"&gt;Blind Blake&lt;/a&gt;, highlighting his dazzling picking.</reviewbody>
    <reviewtitle>"All my life I've been a travelin' man."</reviewtitle>
    <reviewer>PappyK</reviewer>
    <reviewdate>2005-11-27 12:49:57</reviewdate>
    <createdate>2005-11-24 21:44:49</createdate>
    <stars>5</stars>
  </review>
  <review>
    <reviewbody>i first discovered Blind
Blake and Police Dog Blues in 1978 while dating my future husband who is an outstanding blues guitarist. I loaned it out to be re-recorded and never heard it again.  That was about 20 years ago. It is pure and clean and I love it all over again!</reviewbody>
    <reviewtitle>welcome home</reviewtitle>
    <stars>5</stars>
    <reviewer>ksammartine</reviewer>
    <createdate>2006-08-22 02:52:34</createdate>
    <reviewdate>2006-08-22 02:52:34</reviewdate>
  </review>
  <review>
    <reviewbody>I never tire of playin' this after doin' it for som 25 years, even though it took me about 5 years to learn it. Brilliant. Thanks to Stephen Grossman for makin' it available.</reviewbody>
    <reviewtitle>Police dogs go on</reviewtitle>
    <reviewer>grahamb</reviewer>
    <reviewdate>2007-04-27 16:47:29</reviewdate>
    <createdate>2007-04-27 16:47:29</createdate>
    <stars>5</stars>
  </review>
  <review>
    <reviewbody>No sound recordings in the United States (with the exception of Edison records) are in the public domain because they are covered by the common law of the state the contract for the recording was signed in.&#13;
&#13;
The reason Edison records are in the public domain is only because the Edison family deemed them so and no other reason. &#13;
&#13;
That goes for the other songs posted by PublicDomain4U by a variety of artists. &#13;
&#13;
I wish someone could/would prove me wrong as I'd like to use the songs commercially. So if you can, please do.&#13;
&#13;
See what http://PDinfo.com says on the subject.</reviewbody>
    <reviewtitle>This song is not in the public domain</reviewtitle>
    <reviewer>Yuks</reviewer>
    <reviewdate>2007-09-08 00:40:57</reviewdate>
    <createdate>2007-09-08 00:40:57</createdate>
    <stars>0</stars>
  </review>
  <review>
    <reviewbody>This song is apart from very very funny, stunningly accomplished in its arrangement. Another reviewer states it took him five years to master? yeah, right, took me weeks, to play it, took me 30 years to confidently interpret it, both the lyrics and the beautifully carved instrumental repeats that follow it in every sensual, horrid, comical and outstanding detail. To play the song is not difficult (if you know it's in open d) but to perform it: listen to it , here is a master performing at his peak.</reviewbody>
    <reviewtitle>Funny and stunning</reviewtitle>
    <reviewer>Thaddy</reviewer>
    <reviewdate>2007-10-02 21:13:12</reviewdate>
    <createdate>2007-10-02 21:13:12</createdate>
    <stars>5</stars>
  </review>
  <review>
    <reviewbody>I have to agree with Yuks... in my opinion, pretty much this entire recording archive (78s, cylinder, etc.) is comprised of stolen property.  None of these songs are in the public domain unless the copyright holder put them there.  The big joke is the creative commons system being used on these items by people who have absolutely no copyright claims to the pieces.  I appreciate the work, for example, of the cylinder archivists, who bring priceless recordings to the public.  But they purport to be able to define how I can use the recordings (i.e. no commercial, attribution, etc.) when they do not have that legal right to do so, and in fact, their posting of the material here violate U.S. copyright law.</reviewbody>
    <reviewtitle>Archive of stolen material</reviewtitle>
    <reviewer>Mersh</reviewer>
    <reviewdate>2008-08-31 11:47:43</reviewdate>
    <createdate>2008-08-31 11:47:43</createdate>
    <stars>5</stars>
  </review>
  <review>
    <reviewbody>In fact, U.S. Copyright law has no jurisdiction over sound recordings prior to 1972, EXCEPT: &#13;
&#13;
"Despite the general rule precluding federal copyright protection for pre-1972 sound &#13;
recordings, the 1994 GATT/TRIPS amendments, codified at Section 104A of the Copyright &#13;
Act, extend protection to such recordings when they (a) were first published in a country &#13;
that is a signatory to the Berne Convention, the WIPO Performances and Phonograms &#13;
Treaty, or is a member of the WTO, and (b) were not subsequently published in the &#13;
United States during the 30-day period following that initial publication. §104A(f)(6)(C)- &#13;
(E). &#13;
 &#13;
Consequently, these foreign recordings are protected by federal copyright despite their &#13;
fixation prior to 1972, and their term of protection is the same as it would have been had &#13;
they been protected under U.S. federal law ab initio, i.e., 95 years from publication. &#13;
 &#13;
Virtually all works "restored" under this provision will therefore lapse into the public &#13;
domain sooner than domestic recordings, which will enjoy state law protection until 2067 &#13;
regardless of their initial publication date."&#13;
&#13;
SO...there are conceivably some recordings from 1913 or earlier that were published in a country other than the U.S. without being published again in the U.S. within the 30 days following.</reviewbody>
    <reviewtitle>Stolen from whom? Not a U.S. Copyright concern, in any case...</reviewtitle>
    <reviewer>Chris_Brandt</reviewer>
    <reviewdate>2008-12-07 07:17:58</reviewdate>
    <createdate>2008-12-07 07:17:58</createdate>
    <stars>5</stars>
  </review>
  <review>
    <reviewbody>Thank you for making the song available. It is very good.&#13;
&#13;
Speaking of legal concerns. It is due to the Internet Archive services being located in America that people have these concerns? If so perhaps they should locate them somewhere else.&#13;
&#13;
In the UK at least, copyright on sound recordings only lasts 50 years so anything released from 1958 and before can be openly shared.</reviewbody>
    <reviewtitle>Great recording</reviewtitle>
    <reviewer>infobleep</reviewer>
    <reviewdate>2009-08-05 10:14:20</reviewdate>
    <createdate>2009-08-05 10:14:20</createdate>
    <stars>5</stars>
  </review>
  <info>
    <num_reviews>10</num_reviews>
    <avg_rating>5.00</avg_rating>
  </info>
</reviews>
